Portal 2023-24

[jdcatty]

https://x.com/RossDellenger/status/1752732371764265211?


Just when you thought the situation with the Portal and all the transfers couldn't get worse, this happens and it will. I think there are at least two of these suits, and I believe they will ultimately result in unlimited transfers for these "students". 

[vegashog]

that motion pertains to nil and the ncaa's rule that limits nil discussions until the athlete enrolls in school. it includes transfers, but has nothing else to do with the portal.

and as of now, players can transfer as many times as they want without penalty because of another temporary restraining order.

[Lurk]

The transfer rule is doing more damage than NIL is. It removes any ability to discipline kids when they can transfer any time they get their feelings hurt.

[BleedinRed]

Coaches could stop signing portal kids.  I know, will never happen.  But, that would solve the issue.

Edit: This post was not in response to anyone in particular.

[jdcatty]

that motion pertains to nil and the ncaa's rule that limits nil discussions until the athlete enrolls in school. it includes transfers, but has nothing else to do with the portal.

and as of now, players can transfer as many times as they want without penalty because of another temporary restraining order.

you are right, I didn't make myself clear--I think ultimately there won't be any rules for NIL at all and unlimited transfers will be permanently available.  In my view, this will be very damaging to college sports.

[Elblancodiablo]

you are right, I didn't make myself clear--I think ultimately there won't be any rules for NIL at all and unlimited transfers will be permanently available.  In my view, this will be very damaging to college sports.

Duh

[vegashog]

there's nothing that can be done in regards to nil in it's purest form.

that it's become a bastardized pay for play scam, i think there's something that can be devised that will limit that. it will be up to smarter people than me to figure it out tho.

paying the players would end the multiple transfers. they would be under contracts.

this is ultimately the ncaa's fault for using the 'student athlete' as their sole defense and counting on scotus to somehow limit the free market.

[Elblancodiablo]

there's nothing that can be done in regards to nil in it's purest form.

that it's become a bastardized pay for play scam, i think there's something that can be devised that will limit that. it will be up to smarter people than me to figure it out tho.

paying the players would end the multiple transfers. they would be under contracts.

this is ultimately the ncaa's fault for using the 'student athlete' as their sole defense and counting on scotus to somehow limit the free market.

Easy fix...

No more team colors
No more team jerseys
No mentioning of team name
No mentioning of the university

That would castrate nil pretty quick.

[animal]

Coaches could stop signing portal kids.  I know, will never happen.  But, that would solve the issue.

Edit: This post was not in response to anyone in particular.

Yes this is where I'm at. It won't happen but if you know you are talking to a kid that's on his 2nd or 3rd school maybe it's time to let that one walk. Showing commitment to a program used to be a key performance indicator.