Other College Basketball

Started by Doc Hogaday, Nov 06, 2023, 09:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Show-Me Hog

By the way I share Jay Bilas's repeated and obvious disgust for replays, especially out of bounds replays, at the end of games. There Has To Be A Better Way. (His suggestion was one coach's challenge instead of automatic reviews).

I'm sure I am being Master Of The Obvious, but of course so is he.

BleedinRed

I'm fine with the replays.  Refs can't see the ball roll off a guys hands.  If you're down by 1 and a correct call gives you the ball, I'm for whatever is required to get the call right.  

Jay didn't say shit two minutes earlier when the call went for Michigan.  Went it was our turn to benefit, he didn't give a shit about getting the call correct.  Only that it was rediculous to make the review.  

Show-Me Hog

Quote from: BleedinRed on Dec 13, 2024, 05:01 PMI'm fine with the replays.  Refs can't see the ball roll off a guys hands.  If you're down by 1 and a correct call gives you the ball, I'm for whatever is required to get the call right. 

Jay didn't say shit two minutes earlier when the call went for Michigan.  Went it was our turn to benefit, he didn't give a shit about getting the call correct.  Only that it was rediculous to make the review. 

I've heard him rant about it in other games. About the time it takes. It didn't have anything to do with us.

BleedinRed

Well, he is a fucktard.  I think the system is fine.  

Jostlyn mcCocksack

Today's lineup is the tits...

DirkPiggler

Quote from: BleedinRed on Dec 13, 2024, 05:41 PMWell, he is a fucktard.  I think the system is fine. 

I'd incorporate the one challenge rule for calls prior to the last two minutes. 

It's better to get it right than get it fast. 
Perish peacefully in a warm environment.

BleedinRed

Quote from: DirkPiggler on Dec 14, 2024, 09:03 AMI'd incorporate the one challenge rule for calls prior to the last two minutes. 

It's better to get it right than get it fast. 

I could be swayed to do that.  

Show-Me Hog

Quote from: DirkPiggler on Dec 14, 2024, 09:03 AMI'd incorporate the one challenge rule for calls prior to the last two minutes. 

It's better to get it right than get it fast. 

Well that's the opposite of what Jay & I want -- fewer replays, not more, and especially cutting out all the "going to the monitors" under the last 2 minutes. One coach's challenge under the last 2 minutes is the proposal.


BleedinRed

Had the out of bounds call went Michigans way, we most likely lose on an incorrect call.  Not sure how anyone can be okay with that.  

Show-Me Hog

Quote from: BleedinRed on Dec 14, 2024, 11:24 AMHad the out of bounds call went Michigans way, we most likely lose on an incorrect call.  Not sure how anyone can be okay with that. 

Why would that not have been our challenge?

Hognrock

There needs to be a timer on reviews (1:00 at most) and if a game has a 10+ pt margin within the last minute, reviews only on flagrant fouls.  If the officials can't determine in 1 minute then the call stands.

DirkPiggler

Quote from: BleedinRed on Dec 14, 2024, 11:24 AMHad the out of bounds call went Michigans way, we most likely lose on an incorrect call.  Not sure how anyone can be okay with that. 

We have the means to prevent incorrect calls.  I'm with you...we should use any reasonable means to get it right. 

While we are on the topic, automated strike zones in baseball should have happened years ago. 
Perish peacefully in a warm environment.

DirkPiggler

Quote from: Hognrock on Dec 14, 2024, 11:40 AMThere needs to be a timer on reviews (1:00 at most) and if a game has a 10+ pt margin within the last minute, reviews only on flagrant fouls.  If the officials can't determine in 1 minute then the call stands.

I'm fine with this too. 
Perish peacefully in a warm environment.

Hognrock

Quote from: DirkPiggler on Dec 14, 2024, 11:41 AMWe have the means to prevent incorrect calls.  I'm with you...we should use any reasonable means to get it right. 

While we are on the topic, automated strike zones in baseball should have happened years ago. 

I know you're a Braves fan so just a fun dig on you.  Somebody will create a "Maddux hack" and change it to 6" outside the black program.  But, I agree with the automated strike zone.

Show-Me Hog

I've always liked Buzz Williams. I think he's a heck of a coach. How long has Wade been there, 10 years?

Doc Hogaday

Quote from: Show-Me Hog on Dec 14, 2024, 12:15 PMI've always liked Buzz Williams. I think he's a heck of a coach. How long has Wade been there, 10 years?

Then that means Broome has been at Auburn 12.

It is weird watching UNC without Bacot this year. Pretty sure he was there w/ Rasheed and Stackhouse when we played in the '95 Final Four.
Pants ironed and back for more

Spiderham

Quote from: Doc Hogaday on Dec 14, 2024, 01:12 PMThen that means Broome has been at Auburn 12.

It is weird watching UNC without Bacot this year. Pretty sure he was there w/ Rasheed and Stackhouse when we played in the '95 Final Four.
Bacot has gone on to his real passion as a hat model. 
:D
Oak Grove in the house.

Show-Me Hog

It's weird watching a game, not Arkansas, when you can tell who the announcers really favor. Rafferty and Jay Williams sounded extremely disappointed, like talking in a whisper, when Purdue charged with under a minute left.

All game they've been Purdue-ish.

Thin Red Swine

The refs doing their best to make the Tennessee-Illinois game unwatchable. 

14 fouls called in the first 13 minutes.

flash23

Of course Illinois is currently shooting 7% from 3 tonight.